>>  Preparedness
Heritage of Marksmanship Key to Defeating Al Qaeda in Pakistan?
10/01/08 @ 12:11:13 pm, Categories: Announcements [A], 962 words   English (US)

There is no safety for honest men,
except by believing all possible evil of evil men.

- Edmund Burke (1729-1797) Irish Statesman

“While strangers are brought in to suppress us, our commonwealth, and posterity; while idolatry is maintained, and Christ Jesus His true religion despised, while idle bellies and bloody tyrants, the bishops, are maintained and Christ’s true messengers persecuted; while, finally, virtue is contemned and vice extolled . . . what godly man can be offended that we shall seek reformation of these enormities (yes, even by force of arms, seeing that otherwise it is denied us)? . . .

John Knox of Scotland

John Knox was a Scottish Protestant that led an army to defend freedom of religion in Scotland. All over the world people are still trying to maintain various cultural heritages that have been inherited from their forefathers- some traditions are helpful and some are not so helpful in this rapidly changing world.

Switzerland, long known for the preparedness of its armed citizens, is legendary for its heritage of marksmanship.

XML:

See Switzerland (normally very law-abiding).

XML:

Switzerland is comprised of local cantons that refused to bow to the ambitions of European despots that soon discovered Swiss marksmanship could be formidable (remember William Tell). The situation in countries like Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan, on the other hand, may always have a greater element of chaos than Switzerland because Iraq is a mix of cultures that were artificially combined by the Great Powers of Europe when the Ottoman Empire was divided after World War I.

Every indication is that the Sunni governments in the surrounding Arab nations are starting to accept that Iraq will be governed in a manner that departs from the Sunni despotism that has prevailed for centuries in most of the Middle East. Part of the reason for the change of heart resulted from a hard won recognition that Al Qaeda is the enemy of humanity, including but not limited to Christians, Jews, Sunni and Shia.

Some people insist that President Bush made Al Qaeda bigger and deadlier by invading Iraq. Historians can and will argue for years as to whether Iraq was a threat when we invaded. The consequences of any policy will always have ramifications that go far beyond the human ability to anticipate. The fact is that the people of Iraq are committed to the government that they have achieved and critics that sit at home in the safety of the USA complaining that the Iraqis have not accomplished enough quickly enough are suffering from unrealistic expectations.

The way that all this relates to Switzerland is because of the contrast between the peaceful way of life there and the experience of people in the Middle East.

Life as we know it in North America may continue to unfold peacefully, progressively and prosperously. That is our sincere wish for the coming years. But life provides no guarantees. The benefits of liberty belong to those that are vigilant. Thank God, we do do not live in a country always on the verge of sectarian violence. I also appreciate the fact that we can disagree on political and cultural issues and do so aggressively without resorting to bloodshed. We don’t need a political leader to unite us because the American people know how to agree and disagree intelligently.

On the other hand, the Sindh province of Pakistan (the home of the Bhutto family) is an example of an ethnic group ready to break away from the rest of Pakistan because they distrust the Punjabs.

Sindh is one of the four provinces of Pakistan and historically is home to the Sindhis. Different cultural and ethnic groups also reside in Sindh, including Urdu-speaking people and others who migrated from India at the time of and after independence and partition.

The Punjabis have controlled much of the government and military in Pakistan for some time- they even control the water. The farmers in Sindh province have seen their farms dry up due to Punjabi diversion of rivers that flow between the two provinces.

Last year, the carcasses of thousands of vehicles smoldered for a long distance alongside the highways after Bhutto’s Sindhi followers and others expressed their fury when she was assassinated. Now her husband leads the country which seems to be headed for another crisis after violence in Mumbai allegedly planned by elements within Pakistan’s intelligence agencies.

U.S. foreign policy under the new Obama administration will profoundly shape our relationship with countries such as Pakistan and Idia, inexorably impacting national destinies in ways that cannot be anticipated.

These are all developments that demonstrate to thinking men and women the wisdom of our forefathers. The men that drafted the U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights anticipated situations like the world situation today. The Second Amendment is not premised on the concept that you and I will stand with our deer rifles against professional armies (like the vast armies of China). Nor is it realistic (or legal) to march through our neighborhoods looking for enemies. The premise is that we, the citizens at-large, can choose to become familiar with and own small arms that have military usefulness.

We are guarding the life of the Republic when we worship, when we vote, shop and conduct business, when we go to work and target practice and when we teach our children to hunt. All of these activities are expressions of God-given freedom that the Founders articulated in the United States Constitution, including our freedom to express ourselves and our freedom to become informed about governmental matters.

The Swiss, Punjabis, Sindhis and Urdus (to name a few) are also great people and we will be watching the directions that they take.

See also Counter-Insurgency.

3 comments | Permalink

Comments:

Comment from: northwestdoug [Visitor] Email · http://fwcon.wordpress.com
I became aware of this post just today. I lived in Switzerland as a child for awhile. The country is a veritable fortress. By law, homes are built with bomb shelters. Even scenic tourist spots feature an occasional pill box and concrete tank barriers. I believe the Swiss have an vast amount of armaments safely stashed in mountain tunnels. When I lived there (in Bern and Zurich) it was a common sight to see a young man with a rifle or automatic weapon riding a street car, on his way to target practice. At the time (and it may still be true), all young Swiss men were required by law to be in the reserves and to shoot some number of rounds a month.

Yet Switzerland is a pretty safe place with a low incidence of gun violence.

One final comment: You stated:

The Second Amendment is not premised on the concept that you and I will stand with our deer rifles against professional armies (like the vast armies of China).

I disagree. I think the Second Amendment was very much intended for ordinary citizens who belonged to their village militias to have the right to bear arms -- even military grade weapons for the time. I think the framers had Lexington and Concord (as well as frontier conflicts) in mind when they drafted the second amendment. The colonial system of self defense in 1775 was probably more like the Swiss Reserves today than the relatively few Americans today who own and know how to operate weapons. The Second Amendment is about more than hunting; it's about giving the people the capacity to overthrow oppression from their own government should it ever occur again.

No matter what the framers foresaw or didn't foresee, I believe that guns today should be regulated. I think the gun laws in Washington state are reasonable and work well. And I think the restriction against fully automatic weapons is reasonable.

And I also agree with you that it's wonderful to live in a country with a strong tradition of peaceful dissent and political contest.
PermalinkPermalink 05/13/08 @ 20:50
Comment from: firearms2 [Member] Email
We, the armed citizens, are definitely the last line of defense against foreign and domestic enemies. Deer rifles are good but military weapons are better. One of the goals we have in promoting discussions within this format is to promote cooperation between the civilian militia-at-large and organized police and military organizations. Lebanon and Iraq are both examples of what happens when the armed forces and civilian militias are working at cross-purposes. The concept of a militia-at-large is still a working legal concept in the U.S. Federal law recognizes the unorganized militia, a general class of citizens available to defend in times of trouble, but not organized under a chain of command that poses a threat to law order.

We would like to hear more about the Swiss militia. If one of our readers submits an article we will be glad to publish it.

See Gun Grabbers for more details related to the militia-at-large.
PermalinkPermalink 05/14/08 @ 11:06
Comment from: firearms2 [Member] Email
Additional Comments from Doug King:

I don't know much about the Swiss Reserve system today. I lived there for awhile more than 35 years ago while I was still a kid. A business colleague who was Swiss told me the rate of gun violence is low. He said there are two reasons for that. First, criminals expect potential victims to be armed, at least when they are at home. Second, if anyone uses a military-issue weapon (found in nearly every home) in the commission of a crime, they are tried by the military courts, not the civilian courts. The Swiss philosophy has always been to be militantly neutral with regards to foreign policy and to make the costs of conquest too high for any invader. They are therefore armed to the teeth. That policy helped them avoid two world wars. It also promoted their reputation as a safe and neutral banking haven.

It does make we think, however, about why people need guns. I like having them for self-protection, but my main interest is in target shooting. Go back a few hundred years, and every New England village had its own militia primarily for self-protection against hostile Indians. When the relationship with England turned sour, the militia were already organized and were used to fight the British. Eventually, Washington organized a Federal Army, but that took some time. The frontier rifles (Kentucky rifles) used for hunting were more accurate and deadly than the short-range muskets used by the British. But it raises an interesting question -- do we need a militia today? We have the National Guard and the police. It's hard to imagine that if those agencies turned oppressive that citizens could stand up against them and fight. I can't imagine, for example, having a militia per se in my neighborhood. On the other hand, the Neighborhood Watch concept comes close. So much of our battles (in war, in law enforcement, in politics, etc.) today depend on timely and accurate information, and building up a healthy network of trusted friends is perhaps the closest thing we can have today to the New England militias of long ago.

Regardless of whether militia are needed today, I still support the 2nd Admendment.
PermalinkPermalink 05/18/08 @ 01:12

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))

WTF?
We want to find out what disaster preparedness officials are doing at all levels of government, police and military. And what are the people doing at the grassroots? What do you think needs to be done? Are we safe under the current arrangements? Should we leave the job of keeping us safe to the government? Then why are the federal, state and local governments spending billions to tell we the people to get ready? Maybe we should start heeding the official advice and practice some local homeland security! All good government starts in the family and with neighbors.
blogs
Categories
Archives
January 2009
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 << <   > >>
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
User Functions

Management

Misc

Search

Skins

XML Feeds

links

b2evolution

Credits